« Estimating Your FTP | Main | Off-Season Camp »

08/21/2010

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Ted

Joe, I have also observed lower FTP on the TT bike than on the road bike (by 10-15 watts).
The more aggressive the aero position, the more likely the watts are to be lower.

Ken_sharlin

I completely agree with Coach Friel in this case. The only thing I would add is that no one has mentioned who would use this calculation in the first place. The calculation is only useful for the cyclist who has just purchased a power meter and has not yet had an opportunity to go out and peform a 30 minute time trial effort to determine their true lactate threshold based on their average power output. Perhaps another scenario might be to compare the estimate with the actual to ask whether the cyclist is undertraining or whether (if a large difference exists) the power meter needs to be re-calibrated.

Mahting

Hey Joe, I was a little taken aback by the fact that you could estimate such a thing as FTP because I thought it was more "Scientific". fter reading last weeks post about estimating FTP I went ahead and did it. I will make a few comments prior to saying if it worked or not. I train with power, have a very experienced coach, race as a CAT 2 and am a road rider not a multisporter. I have a very accurate read on my FTP. The estimation was almost spot on if I would train specificly for it, however training for crits chages that a little but I was impressed.

Joe Friel

Ted, Yes a very good observation. The more aero you become the more power you sacrifice. It can be a very good trade off for TT and tri however.

Pat

Can FTP be improved? Using your estimation, and testing with my power meter, I seem to be about 30W short of where I should be... can I expect to make up that 30W, or more, in one year of training?

Flemish cyclist

Hi, calculated 262 W, measured 260 W. Wow !

Joe Friel

Pat--It certainly can as I mentioned with examples in my last post on this topic. can you do it in one year? Too many "it depends" to be able to answer that. The last one I mentioned is a pretty basic "it depends" --how many times you ride in a week chronically.

Ethan

Joe- As a cyclist in my 2nd year of riding I'm not sure if my body can handle lot's of training hours week to week. I've been averaging about 10 hours/wk (with some variation depending on the period that I'm in). Two quick questions: Since more saddle time=higher FTP, should we aim for the highest number of yearly hours that we can handle without it having a negative impact on form? And as we become more experienced (from years and years of riding) is a cyclist's body typically able to handle a higher load of workout stress?

Joe Friel

Ethan--Thanks for your comment. Being a bit conservative is always wise regardless of one's experience in the sport. It's just that the absolute volume tends to rise as more experience (and resistance to injury, illness, etc) improves. Ride at a volume always that allows for performance improvement. The key to this is adequate recovery weekly, monthly and annually. All of this is explained in my Cyclist's (and Triathlete's and Mountain Biker's) Training Bible.

Sean

"So why do I think this happened for each of these triathletes? More time in the saddle."

So does this not say:

More Training = Higher FTP

And does this not go against your basic premise about quality (volume) of training versus quantity?

BTW you are missing the beautiful 110 degree riding weather here in Scottsdale.

Joe Friel

Sean--More time in the saddle also means more opportunities to do quality training.

Lisa

Hi Joe - I'm beginning power training with my indoor cycling class, and have just finished a 30 minute test with them - gave them the chart with percentages to fill in. Here's the problem I encounter when adapting power testing to indoor cycling classes: all of the tests are premised on either an outside ride or an indoor ride in the saddle (efficiency decreases so much out of the saddle). Some of my people do not even ride outdoors, so I want the training to be useful to them as well - they like being out of the saddle - a lot. How do I maintain the accuracy of power zones as measures of intensity and give them the time out of the saddle that they want? I've considered doing separate testing to measure zones out of the saddle - does that make any sense?

Joe Friel

Lisa--Thanks for your comment. Either in or out of saddle is ok for FTP testing. I really don't care which my athletes do. I know they won't stay out of the saddle for 30 minutes straight or in for that matter. They'll undoubtedly do both when riding in a workout anyway. Some are actually slightly more economical when standing. And the economy difference between seated and standing is really insignificant. It's roughly 20-25% for everyone. A much greater concern is the temp of the room they are riding in and the wind moving over their bodies. That's a huge variable.

Angela

I agree with more time on the saddle will improve FTP. I tested this last year, for three base periods riding 18-20 hours per week. At the end, I surprised myself seeing a big 25% increase in my power from my last FTP test done. Believe me, I was very happy and re-tested the following week to make sure the power tap is not broken or reading incorrectly. pretty cool...

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Loading

December 2014

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner